William S. and Christine S. Hall Center for Law and Health

December 2008

In this issue...

Welcome

Current Developments

Upcoming Events

News

Welcome

Greetings to all.
The Health Law Society (HLS) has had a productive and interesting semester thus far, hosting several well-attended events.  On September 9th, in collaboration with the Indianapolis Bar Association's Health Law Section, the HLS convened a panel of diverse speakers to address strategies for getting hired via the law school's On-Campus Interview process.  On September 16th, the HLS co-hosted the Center for Law & Health's Annual Open House and Student Reception .  The formal portion of the evening provided students with an opportunity to learn about the Center's activities, the health law concentration, the joint-degree programs offered through the Center and the three affiliated student organizations.  The reception that followed allowed students the opportunity to network with academic leadership, practicing health law attorneys and other students sharing similar interests in the healthcare industry.  The most recent activity organized by the HLS was the October 29th event, Framing the Issues on the Left & Right: a Debate on Health Reform .  In this debate, Aaron Carroll, MD, MS and Associate Professor of Medicine at Indiana University argued for a single-payer healthcare system while Dr. David Hyman, MD, JD and Professor of Law and Medicine at the University of Illinois advocated for a purely market-driven system.  This event was also hosted by the Center for Law & Health and the Consortium for Health Policy, Law & Bioethics.

The HLS has participated in two additional events this fall, one supporting a worthy cause and the other a purely social event for society members.  The HLS, together with the Feminist Law Society and the LAMBDA Law Society, helped to support the Indiana Coalition Against Sexual Abuse's Annual Mock Trial.  The trial, was held on November 14th in the Wynne Courtroom beginning at 8:30 a.m.,  and focused on aspects of prosecution specific to cases of sexual assault involving same-sex intimate partners.  Lastly, the HLS wrapped up the semester with good conversation and food at the 2008 Smokin' Chili Cook-Off held at Professor Eleanor Kinney's home on Friday, November 21st from 7:00-10:00 p.m.

The HLS is very excited to announce that it has been working with the Center for Law & Health's Steering Committee to institute a new mentor program pairing interested HLS members with practicing health law attorneys in the Indianapolis area.  Initial pairings have been made and the program will be rolled out in the coming weeks.  Please contact Amy Lewis Gilbert at amylewis@iupui.edu if you are interested in participating as either a student or attorney mentor.

Details about upcoming events can be found on the HLS webpage:  http://indylaw.indiana.edu/centers/clh/student/HLS/ 

Current Developments

rkatzmThe Business in Human Tissue
By Robert A . Katz, Professor of Law, Indiana University School of Law Indianapolis

A deceased person's non-organ tissues can be processed into therapeutic implants or "allografts" that
enhance the quality of recipients' lives.  Cadaveric bones can be used for spinal fusions, veins for bypass surgery, and skin for grafts.  Although transplantable tissues are more widely available than organs, certain types of tissues are in short supply.  The demand for transplant tissues is likely to grow as new uses are found, new allograft forms are developed, and the population ages.  Read more...

DonohoeThe End of Community Benefit? 
Tax-Exempt Status Under President-Elect Obama's Health Care Proposal
By Tom Donohoe, '08, Associate, Hall, Render, Killian, Heath & Lyman P.C.

Over the past couple of years, tax-exempt hospitals have been under growing scrutiny regarding their tax-exempt status.  United States senators have convened workgroups and hearings to study whether the community benefits provided by tax-exempt healthcare entities warrants the substantial tax exemption they receive.  The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has recently revised Form 990 and its accompanying schedules, including Schedule H, requiring more information from tax-exempt hospitals regarding their activities and their community benefit.  While these congressional and administrative bodies have increased their level of scrutiny of tax-exempt hospitals, state courts have begun to revoke tax-exempt hospitals' property exemptions based on finding that the community benefits rendered are inadequate.  While this flurry of activity at both the state and federal levels has the tax-exempt community wondering what lawmakers, regulators, and courts will do next, few have considered the effect president-elect Obama's healthcare proposals would have on the community benefit standard.  Read more...

Getting Past the Emergency Room: Dilemmas U.S. Hospitals Face in Treating Uninsured, Illegal Immigrants
By Alexandria Assareh, 3L

Uninsured immigrants who are gravely injured or seriously ill have few choices in the type of long-term medical care they receive.  In fact, the way the American health care system handles cases involving uninsured immigrants is so erratic that whether such patients receive sustained care in this country or are privately deported by a hospital depends on what emergency room they initially visit.  Read more...

The First Major Civil Rights Act of the Century: The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008
By Miriam E. Huck, 2L

In 1995, the first federal legislation to prevent the misuse of genetic information was introduced.  Genetic information is obtained from genetic tests that not only allow medical professionals to confirm a suspected genetic disease, but also screen for genes that pre-dispose patients to certain diseases.  At the time of the 1995 legislation, roughly 300 genetic tests were available, and they mostly screened for rare diseases.  Thus, many people felt that such legislation was premature; as a result, this and later-proposed legislation did not pass.

Fast forward 13 years-the human genome has been sequenced and there are now over 1,500 genetic tests available, many of them for common diseases....Although no case has ever gone to trial over health insurance or employer-related genetic discrimination, evidence indicates that patients often refuse genetic tests and do not participate in clinical research trials for fear that insurance companies and employers might gain access to these records.  Read more...


 

Upcoming Events

December 8 -9, 2008
The Medical Technology Leadership Forum
FDA in the 21st Century: Issues and Their Impact on Medical Techonolgy
For more information please see http://www.mtlf.org/docs/Agenda111408.pdf

December 11, 2008
The Hall Center for Law and Health
Invites YOU (colleagues, students, staff, alumni and friends) to Light up the Holiday Season with a Party
3:00 pm - 5:00 pm
Hall Center, Inlow Hall, Room 136

February 25, 2009
McDonald-Merrill-Ketcham Lecture/Indiana Health Law Review Symposium
Beyond Band Aids: How to Cure America's Ailing Health Care System
Speaker: Ezekiel Emanuel, M.D., Ph.D., National Institutes of Health (NIH)
Time: TBA
Location: Inlow Hall
CLE and CME credit (pending approval)
Contact: Contact Carsandra Knight for more information: (317) 274-1912

News

hallNew Adjunct Professor: Mr. Ralph Hall

The Indiana University School of Law Indianapolis is pleased to announce that Mr. Ralph Hall will be an adjunct professor for the spring semester. He will be teaching food and drug law which he currently teaches at University of Minnesota along with negotiation, ADR, and corporate compliance courses. Mr. Hall is also currently working on a natural science foundation grant concerning the regulatory oversight of nanotechnology including but not limited to Food and Drug Administration, Environmental Protection Agency and Agricultural concerns.  Professor Hall works for Baker & Daniels in their food and drug law and corporate compliance divisions.  He has several publications on a variety of health law issues including, but not limited to, nanotechnology, compliance, and clinical trials. Professor Hall has extensive experience in the area of food and drug law, health care law and corporate compliance.  "We are thrilled that Professor Hall is sharing his wealth of knowledge in the the health law field with our students," says Professor Eleanor Kinney. 

morrisemilyNew Associate Professor of Law: Ms. Emily Morris

The Indiana University School of Law Indianapolis is excited to welcome Associate Professor Emily Morris to their faculty. She teaches patent law, copyright law and intellectual property courses and is interested in health law and bioethics law. Prior to joining the Indiana University School of Law Indianapolis faculty Professor Morris was a visiting associate professor at Chicago-Kent College of Law, where she taught both Patent Law and Patent Litigation. She earned her A.B. (magna cum laude) from Harvard University and her J.D. from the University of Michigan Law School (magna cum laude ), where she was an articles editor on the Michigan Law Review . After law school, Professor Morris clerked for the Honorable Bruce M. Selya on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, and then worked for three years as an associate in the Issues & Appeals section of the Washington, DC office of Jones Day. She also served as an adjunct assistant professor and Humphrey Fellow in Law and Economic Policy at the John M. Olin Center for Law and Economics, University of Michigan Law School.  Professor Eleanor Kinney says, "Professor Morris is a wonderful addition to the Indiana University School of Law-Indianapolis faculty."

consortium150Consortium for Health Policy, Law and Bioethics

The Indiana University Center for Bioethics, the Hall Center for Law and Health and the new Center for Health Policy share a commitment to interdisciplinary inquiry and research. Collectively they contain different but complementary skills and expertise in ethics, law and policy. Moreover, they share a common research vision, interests and values in areas of the life sciences. To advance these common interests, the centers established the Consortium for Health Policy, Law and Bioethics, an IUPUI Signature Center. The director's of the three consortium centers serve as co-directors of the Consortium and are Professor Eleanor Kinney for the Hall Center for Law and Health, Professor Eric Meslin for the IU Center for Bioethics and Professor Eric Wright for the Center for Health Policy. The founding vision is to create an innovative and dynamic environment to facilitate research, education, and public policy service on issues in health care, health and science policy, and the life sciences. The consortium is not a new program or center. Rather it is an initiative to enhance the capacity of the three participating centers and to lay the groundwork for other programs and centers to work in areas of common interest. The Consortium's mission is to provide an innovative, interdisciplinary organizational environment that enhances existing IUPUI/IU capacity in health policy, law and bioethics. The Consortium will strive to inform social and public policy in health, facilitate cross-cutting interdisciplinary research, and support current and developing degree and certificate programs. The Consortium will fulfill its mission through education, research, and public outreach/service functions.  To contribute to the educational attribute of the Consortium the Health Law E-newsletter hopes to begin to include articles that incorporate not only health law but bioethics and health policy issues.  For more information about the Consortium for Health Policy, Law and Bioethics please visit their website at http://hplb.iupui.edu/index.html.


IU Law - Indianapolis

Lawrence W. Inlow Hall
530 West New York Street
Indianapolis, IN 46202-3225
Tel. 317-274-8523 Fax 317-274-3955
Comments: eallingt@iupui.edu
http://indylaw.indiana.edu